Call: 314.588.9500 SEARCH SITE:

MMPA Claims Accrue When Damage Capable of Discovery

The Missouri Court of Appeals recently gave a refresher course on the time of accrual for claims under the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act (“MMPA”).  In Ball v. Friese Construction Co., the plaintiff brought suit against the defendant for violations of the MMPA, among other things, relating to the construction of the appellant’s house in 2001.  The appellant filed his petition on May 28, 2010, nearly ten years after the home was constructed.

Notably, the plaintiff’s MMPA claim was governed by the five-year limitations period set forth in Section 516.120, RSMo., which provides for a five-year statute of limitations for liabilities created by statute.  The issue before the court was whether the plaintiff’s claims were barred by Section 516.120.

In its opinion, the court reiterated that “the statute of limitations [in Missouri] is triggered not by discovery of damage, but by the commencement of the right to sue,” and that these two events do not necessarily coincide.  Indeed, pursuant to Section 516.100, RSMo., the triggering event of the applicable statute of limitations is when (1) damage is sustained, and (2) the damage becomes capable of ascertainment.

As to the first element, the Missouri Court of Appeals noted that a claimant must have at least nominal damage to bring suit.  The second element requires a more complex analysis.  Commonly known as the “capable of ascertainment” standard, the second element is an objective standard whereby the court considers whether the “evidence was such to place a reasonably prudent person on notice of a potentially actionable injury.”  More specifically, the test to be applied is “when a reasonable person would have been put on notice that an injury and substantial damages may have occurred and would have undertaken to ascertain the extent of the damages.”

In order for the statute of limitations to accrue, the claimant must have (1) knowledge of the wrong and at least nominal damage, or (2) knowledge of something that puts the claimant on notice to inquire further.  In sum, “a cause of action accrues [under Missouri law] when the damage can be discovered, not when it is actually discovered.”  (emphasis added).

Relying upon the foregoing caselaw, the Missouri Court of Appeals held that the plaintiff’s MMPA claim was barred by the statute of limitations.  In support, the court noted that the record indicated that the plaintiff had reason to believe his basement floor was heaving due to water underneath the floor slab in 2002, well over five years prior to the time he filed his petition.  “At that point, a reasonably prudent person would have been put on notice of a potentially actionable injury; thus the statute of limitations began to run.”

Weiss Attorneys at Law provides guidance and representation regarding real and personal property matters, including Missouri Merchandising Practices Act claims.  If confronted with such a contractual issue, please contact the attorneys at Weiss Attorneys at Law


Email to someoneShare on FacebookGoogle+Share on LinkedInTweet about this on Twitter

By submitting a comment below, you acknowledge and agree that:

  1. No attorney-client relationship has been or is created by submission of this query;
  2. Any information you submit to Weiss Attorneys at Law, including attachments, if any, whether with this query or separately, will not be treated as confidential information or secrets of yours by the attorneys of this law firm;
  3. No legal advice will have been deemed to have been given by submitting this query;
  4. The attorneys of Weiss Attorneys at Law will not be prevented from representing a party adverse to the Sender?s (your) or his/her/their position;
  5. No attorney-client relationship will be deemed to have been created until a legal representation agreement in form submitted by attorney is executed by you and returned to this firm along with the required retainer; and
  6. The additional disclaimers referenced at the bottom of this page are hereby incorporated by this reference.